Linking of birth and death data to NPR unconstitutional: Asad Owaisi

Opposing the proposed amendments to the Registration of Birth and Death Act, Owaisi has written a letter to the Registrar General of India detailing his suggestions.

All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) president and Hyderabad MP Barrister Asaduddin Owaisi has opposed the proposed amendments to the Registration of Births and Deaths Act (RBD), 1969 stating that they violate the fundamental right to privacy.

Asad Owaisi on Friday tweeted a copy of his suggestion to the Registrar of India, opposing the amendment to the act.

“Wrote to Office of Registrar General of India, Ministry of Home Affairs opposing the proposed amendments to link registration of births & deaths to #NPR, electoral rolls, passports, etc. It is a dangerous & illegal proposal that does not serve ANY public interest,” he tweeted.

What’s the proposed amendment?

The proposed amendment to the RBD Act as subsection 3(3A) states, “The Registrar General, India shall maintain the database of registered births and deaths at the national level, that may be used, with the approval of the Central government, to update the Population Register prepared under the Citizenship Act, 1955; electoral registers or electoral rolls prepared under the Representation of the People Act, 1951; Aadhaar database prepared under the Aadhaar Act, 2016; ration card database prepared under the National Food Security Act, 2013; passport database prepared under the Passport Act; and the driving licence database under the Motor Vehicles (Amendment) Act, 2019, and other databases at the national level subject to provision of Section 17 (1) of the RBD Act, 1969.”

In other words, the amendment states that records of births and deaths will be maintained in a unified database, on a state level, by a states-appointed Chief Registrar. The unified database will then be integrated with data at the national level. Currently, the record of births and deaths is maintained by a local registrar, appointed by states.

Owaisi’s suggestions

Owaisi in his memorandum to the Office of Registrar General of India has detailed some suggestions arguing that the act “attacks the very foundation of the individual’s right to privacy”. He states that the amendment violates the principle of purpose limitation, unlike the other acts that clearly state the necessity of data collection.

“The Citizenship Act, 2003 only calls for registration of citizens but has no mention of enumeration of usual residents. The act also does not have provisions to specify procedures of citizenship verification nor does it give special powers to registrars.” reads Owaisi’s letter.

It further states that there must be a statute for infringing upon the right to privacy of an individual, which does not exist in the case of the National Population Register (NPR).

Owaisi expresses that the collection of demographic and identifiable data of usual residents is unconstitutional and alleges that updating the NPR by the collection of data in an unconstitutional manner is the Government’s first step towards the controversial National Register of Citizens. He also says that it also violates the “essential principle of the right to privacy that gives individuals protection from excess collection and storage of data,”.

Owaisi has also dismissed the proposed amendment’s need to collect data to update AADHAR and electoral databases, saying that it violates the principle of informed consent. He says that the data collected could be misused for “targetted disenfranchisement and voter suppression”.

Stating that the government has not declared the advantages of such interlinking, Owaisi claims that it does not serve the public interest. He goes on to call the proposal “highly dangerous”, stating that it may negatively impact the “purity of the electoral process and independence guaranteed by Article 324 of the constitution India to the Election Commission of India (ECI).”

Owaisi also said that the government has failed to show the cause and aim of such data collection which may be misused for unconstitutional purposes. “The government has no legitimate state-aim as to why such large integration of data is required. Mere administrative convenience is not an acceptable ground to such an attack on citizen’s right to privacy,” the letter states.

“Even if there is a valid objective, to the collection of data the government has not provided proof as to why this method of centralisation of databases is the best method to do so,” he states. He also warned the government that such large databases are susceptible to being breached and no degree of security is adequate.


Next Story :

  • Bandi Sanjay Calls on MP Aravind

    Bandi Sanjay Calls On MP Aravind

    State BJP president Bandi Sanjay Kumar today called on the party MP from Nizamabad D. Aravind at Nandipeta of Nizamabad and inquired about his well-being.


  • CM KCR is Ignoring Farmers’ Deaths in Telangana: YS Sharmila

    CM KCR Is Ignoring Farmers’ Deaths In Telangana: YS Sharmila

    Continuing her attack on the Chief Minister of the state K Chandrasekhar Rao, the founder president of YSRTP YS Sharmila today alleged that the CM was ignoring the suicides of the farmers of the state.


  • Nabard Releases Rs 1.66 lakh cr Vision Plan: Niranjan Reddy

    Nabard Releases Rs 1.66 Lakh Cr Vision Plan: Niranjan Reddy

    Agriculture Minister S Niranjan Reddy today urged that NABARD should extend funding and cooperation for alternate crops by farmers in the state. Nabard has released a vision document agriculture plan of Rs 1,66,384 cr for 2022-23 financial year in the state.


  • CM KCR Phones Megastar Chiranjeevi

    CM KCR Phones Megastar Chiranjeevi

    Chief Minister K Chandrasekhar Rao today called up Megastar Chiranjeevi and inquired about his well-being after the latter tested positive to the deadly Coronavirus . During his telephonic conversation, the CM wished that megastar recovered fast from the virus.


  • Council Protem Chairman offers Oath to 4 new Members

    Council Protem Chairman Offers Oath To 4 New Members

    Telangana State Legislature Council Protem Chairman Syed Aminul Jaffery today administered the oath of office and secrecy to four newly elected members. Those who took oath include P Mahender Reddy, Kasireddy Narayan Reddy, Yadava Reddy and L Ramana.


Now you can get latest stories from Indtoday on Telegram everyday. Click the link to subscribe.  Click to follow Indtoday Facebook page and Twitter and on Instagram. For all the latest Hyderabad News updates

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.